Each year selections are made for the Hall of Fame based on their contributions to old-time fiddling, performing, teaching, and love of humanity. The plaques are displayed at Marcella's Eatery and Ice Cream Parlor in Jonesville, Michigan.

The inductees are:

1997
Lew Smith
Ted Miller

1998
Varsal Fales
Russ Nelson

1999
James "Tex" Brown
Salty Kline

2000
Del Bassett
Milford Dunn

2001
Bill Carr
Dane Johnson

2002
Bill Ernst
Iszy Miller-Buchanan

2003
Dick Wild
Les Raber

2004
Robert "Bob" Burghdoff
Ralph Shaver

2005
Charlene "Char" Wild
Robert "Bob" Murphy

2006
Alice Meyers
Willard Myers

2007
Don Wilson
Joe Andrews

2008
Larry Williams
Garland Buhrer

2009
Bill Sparrow